ETHIC OF CARE:
An ethic that emphasizes cring for the concrete well being of those near to us.
ETHIC OF VIRTUE:
An ethic based on evaluations of the moral character of persons or groups.
A general term for any view that holds that actions and policies should be evaluated on the basis of the benefits and costs they will impose on society.
The inclusive term used to refer to any net benefits produced by an action.
- Advocates maximising utility.
- Matches well with moral evaluations of public policies
- Appears intuitive to many people
- Helps Explain why some actions are generally wrong and others are generally light.
- Influenced Economics
COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS:
A type of analysis used to determine the desirability of investing in a project by figuring whether its present and future economic benefits outweight its present and future economic costs.
Operating in such a way that one produces a desired output with the lowest resource input.
Goods such as life, love, freedom,equality, health, beauty, whose value is such that no quantity of any economic good is equal in value to the value of the noneconomic good.
Things that are considered valuable because they lead to other good things.
Things that are desirable independent of any other benefits they may produce.
Distributing benefits and burdens fairly among people.
Individual entitlements to freedom of choice and well being.
- Critics say not all values can be measured.
- Utilitarians respond that monetary and commonsensee mesures can measure everything.
- Critics say utilitarianism fails with rights and justice.
- Utilitarians respond that rule – utilitariansim can deal with rights and justice.
An entitlement that derives from a legal system that permits or empowers a person to act in a specified way or that requires others to act in certain ways toward that person.
Rights that human beings of every nationality possess to an equal extent simply virtue of being human beings.
CHARACTERISTICS OF RIGHTS:
- A right is an individual’s entitlement to something.
- Rights derieved from legal systems are limited by jurisdiction
- Moral or human rights are based on moral norms and are not limited by jurisdiction.
SUMMARY OF MORAL RIGHTS:
- Tigthly correlated with duties.
- Provide individuals with autonomy and equality in the free pursuit of their interests.
- Provide a basis for justifying one’s actions and for invoking the protection or aid of thers.
Duties others have to not interfere in certain activities of the person who holds the right.
Duties of other agent to provide the holder of the right with whatever he or she needs to freely pursue his or her interests.
KINDS OF MORAL RIGHTS:
- Negative rights require others leave us alone
- Positive rights require others help us
- Contractual or special rights require other to keep agreements.
The requirement that everyone should be treated as a free person equal to everyone else.
The reason a person in a certain situation has for doing what he or she plans to do.
The person’s reasons for acting must be reasons that everyone could act on atleast in principle.
The person’s reasons for acting must be reasons that he or she would be willing to have all others use, even as a basis of how they treat him or her.
KANT’S CATEGORICAL IMPERATIVE FORMULAS:
- Never do something unless you are willing to have everyone do it.
- Never use people merely as means, but always respect and develop their ability to choose for themselves.
CRITICISMS OF KANT:
- Categorical Imperatives are unclear
- Kant’s rights can conflict
- Kant’s theory implies some mistaken moral conclusions
- Believe that freedom from human constraint is necessarily good and that all constraints imposed by others are necessarily evil except when needed to prevent the imposition of greater human constraints.
TYPES OF JUSTICE:
- Distributive Justice: Just distribution of benefits and burdens
- Retributive Justice: Just imposition of punishments and penalities.
- Compensatory Justice: Just compensation for wrongs or injuries.
Distributive society’s benefits and burdens fairly.
Blaming or punishing persons fairly for doing wrong.
Restoring to a person what the person lost when he or she was wronged by someone.
Every person should be given exactly equal shares of a society’s or a group’s benefits and burdens.
Equal participation in, and treatment by, the political system.
Equality of income, wealth and opportunity.
The view that every individual has a religious obligation to work hard at his calling (the career to which God summons each individual).
The view that values individual effort and believes that hard work does and should lead to success.
The amount a person produces.
PRINCIPLE OF EQUAL LIBERTY:
The claim that each citizen’s liberties must be protected from invasion by others and must be equal to those of others.
The claim that a productive society will incorporate inequalities, but takes steps to improve the position of the most needy members of society.
PRINCIPLE OF FAIR EQUALITY OF OPPORTUNITY:
The claim that everyone should be given an equal opportunity to qualify for the more privileged positions in society’s institutions.
An imaginary meeting of rational self interested persons who must choose the principles of justice by which their society will be governed.
VEIL OF IGNORANCE:
The requirement that persons in the original position must not know particulars about themselves which might bias their choices such as their sex,race,religino,income,social status etc.,
PRINCIPLES OF DISTRIBUTIVE JUSTICE:
- Fundamental: Distributive benefits and burdens equally to equals and unequally to unequals.
- Egalitarian: Distribute equally to everyone.
- Capitalist: Distribute by Contribution
- Socialist: Distribute by need and ability.
- Libertarian: Distribute by Free Choices
- Rawls: Distribute by equal liberty, equal opportunity, and needs of disadvantaged.
ETHIC OF CARE:
An ethic that emphasizes caring for the concrete well being of those near to us.
- Claims ethics need to be impartial.
- Emphasizes preserving and nurturing concrete valuable relationships.
- Says we should care for those dependent on and related to us.
An ethic that sees concrete communities and communal relationships as having a fundamental value that should be preserved and maintained.
Objection to Care Approach to Ethics:
- Charge: Ethic of care can degenerate into favoritism.
- Response: Conflicting moral demands are an inherent characteristic of moral choices.
- Charge: Ethic of care can lead to “burnout”
- Response: Adequate understanding of ethic of care will address the need to care for the caregiver.
The Basis of Moral Judgements:
- Evaluations of social costs and benefits.
- Respect for individual rights.
- Just ditribution of benefits and burdens.
- Caring for those in concrete relationships.
An acquired disposition that is valued as part of th character of morality good human being and that is exhibited in the person’s habitual behaviour.
THEORIES OF MORAL VIRTUE:
- Aristotle: Habits that enable a person to live according to reason.
- Aquinas: Habits that enable a person to live responsibly in this world and be united with God in the next life.
- MacIntyre: Disposition that enables a person to achieve the good at which human”practices” aim.
- Pincoff: Dispositions we use when choosing between persons or potential future selves.
The theory that the aim of the moral life is to develop those general dispositions called moral virtues, and to exercise and exhibit them in the many situations that human life sets before us.
VIRTUE THEORY CLAIMS:
- We should exercise, exhibit, and develop the virtues.
- We should avoid exercising, exhibiting, and developing vices.
- Institutions should instill virtues not vices.